I really like these lip glosses; they are very moisturizing and although some shades seem more sheer than others, they still give off good color. I think the creams are more opaque than the frosts are. I also like that the frosted shades are not "metallic"; they give more of a "pearly" finish.
Some people are put-off by the caramel-vanilla-cotton candy scent, but it does not bother me. It reminds me of candied caramel apples at an amusement park; Yummy! LOL
The applicator is very nice also; L'Oreal and Lancome has done a very good job in that department.
The color I chose, "Euphoric" is a light pink frost and although it looks a bit intense in the tube, it looks more of a soft baby pink on your lips; very pretty! Looks awesome with a pink lip liner! Very pretty for the summer time:-)
I hope L'Oreal has plans to extend their H.I.P. cosmetic line; I think it's quite good.